I ordered the perfect leather pump in Saddle Brown (a rich neutral for Spring/Summer) in sz 5 for
Their signature pump also comes in exotic (4 color choices), patent, and linen. I own a pair of the exotics and they ran slightly larger than my leather ones. In general, I find that AT runs bigger than other brands. I am a true 5.5, but I take a 5 in these shoes. It's rare to have such a large selection of colors and materials in small sizes at this price, so take advantage if you've been considering these!